While I'd like to encourage fan productions, I didn't like this one. It just tapped into my 2 pet peeves:
1.) Temperal Cold War --- This killed ST Enterprise
2.) They give a nod to JJ Abrams' destruction of Romulus.
Of my pet peeves, #2 is unforgivable. I would bite my tongue and never say a bad word about this movie, but once you give Abrams a nod, you are a disgrace to Star Trek.
Other than that, he acting and the casting weren't too bad.