When I saw that film, I kept expecting the Enterprise to swoop in at the last minute and "Conundrum" the Cylon Raiders. It surprised me when they blew up the Galactica. At the same time, when the second ship dropped out of warp, I was thinking, "Overkill, much?"
And when I say "Conundrum", I mean the scene from :23 to :27 of this clip.