There were a few things I disliked about Trek III
1/ You killed Spock he is DEAD go on from there.
2/ Klingons in Romulan ships.
3/ The Klingon Captains pet.
4/ Hey BONEHEAD you only have 12 crew and you're behind enemy lines, you don't execute any of them on a whim, you don't have any to spare.
1. Yeah, Spock died, but it upset a lot of fans so they brought him back, and bribed Leonard Nimoy into agreeing by letting him direct (the reason they killed Spock was because Nimoy hated being type cast, and only agreed to come back for WoK if they killed the character).
2. I don't recall the Romulan bird of prey even remotely resembling the Klingon one, and if I had to place the BoP in any trek race based on its shape, it would be the Klingons.
3. Klingons wallow in filth, is it surprising that he would have an animal like that on his bridge
4. The idiot disobeyed a direct order and fired to destroy when he was ordered to disable. Executing him was hardly satisfying a whim.
You know, I really really like ST: Nemesis. I think it get's an unfair rap from some hardcore trekkies who are just a little too nitpicky about it.
It was a FAR better MOVIE (though one may say it wasn't better trek) then Insurrection, Generations, the original Motion Picture, or the Final Frontier...In MY OPINION.
I wouldn't say I really liked Nemesis, (had the same trek issue of WTF did these Remans come from, and why am I supposed to believe miner picard guy is an awesome spaceship commander), but I'll agree I liked it far more then Insurrection,Generations, Final Frontier.
VI was the best imo, but Christopher Plummer really made it for me. He simply seemed to be having so much fun.
I consider Nemesis to be the worst Trek film (I don't consider that PoS that Abrams produced to be Star Trek). That said, its still better than any of the other sci-fi films that were produced around that time. As for Shinzon being a starship commander, they explained that in the film. The Romulans would regularly draft Remans to run the military missions which they considered too dangerous to risk Romulan lives on. During the dominion war Shinzon gained a lot of experience as a tactician. Also, you really don't know how awesome he was a starship commander considering that the ships weren't exactly equal.