You say that it will be highly moddable. Does that include editing and adding weapons? The debate about SFB could be largely solved by making almost everything editable. That way non-purists could have seeking photon torpedoes, or different powered disruptors, or even totally new weapons for Gorns and Tholians, while purists can have their drones and energy photon torpedoes. If the map is editable, then cannon purists can have Ferengis and Cardassians along with Lyrans and Hydrans.
One of my fantasies, if I won the lottery, was to commission an SFC based game that would be completely customizable, but would be distributed with some original races and ships, so as to skirt most legal issues. Players would have the freedom to make the game into almost anything they want, a computerized SFB, a cannon simulator, etc. They would even be able to change the effectiveness of the cloak, so SFB purists could have their half hearted cloak, while cannon purists could have perfect invisibility. There could even be different types of cloaks, to simulate the evolution from TOS to TNG invisibility. Maybe even the Mauler could be edited to take energy from the warp or impulse generator, with a cooling off time, to make a realistic Wave Motion Gun.
Are you sure this isn't a joke? Why is this not in the SFC Open Source forum, since that would seem the proper place for it? Why does the little announcement in that forum end with "snicker"?