Why does a person who's ship gets destroyed have to be banned at all? I thought the initial intent of the Disengagement Rule was to discourage people from running and promote PvP by providing a penalty that might be worse than attacking. The loss of an expensive ship is bad enough or do you no longer use Cost of Build OOB?
There hasn't been OoB for a number of campaigns now. Anyone can fly the larger stuff, so long as the total number of points is below whatever the max is.
Are there VC's for bagging kills or can you get destroyed as much as you like?
As an example, here is the PvP kill section of the rules from SGO7:
PvP Kills: (PvP Points)
- You earn PvP (Player vs. Player) Points when you kill enemy players. Report kills here: SGO7 Kills Thread
- Total PvP points will be calculated at the end of each week to determine VC's. See below.
- PvP kills are worth the following points:
I-CCX 6 (1 move cost)
All other CCX/CAX 4 (1 move cost)
I-CLX 3 (.67 move cost)
CLX 2 (.67 move cost)
FFX/DDX 1 (.5 move cost)
BB: 16 (2 move cost)
CVA: 8 (1.5 move cost)
DN: 6 (1.25 and 1.5 move cost)
BCV/T - Carrier, Casual (2 PF's) or Full Tender (3+ PF's): 4 (1 and 1.25 move cost)
BC/H: 3 (1 and 1.25 move cost) (Includes all Lyran BC's with 2 PF's)
N/CA, N/CL, HDW's are worth 1. (.67 and 1 move cost)
Smaller class types with 8 ftrs or 3+ PF's are worth 1.
Ships with a move cost of .5 or less are exempt unless they are involved in a fleet action with a live player wing, or used in a Multi-Ship Fleet, or deep striking in which case they are worth 1.
PF Flotillas are exempt unless they are involved in a fleet action with a wing in which case they are worth 1 only if the PF-(Flt) Leader is destroyed.
FF Squadrons are worth 1 if any two of the three FF's are destroyed.
- PvP kills do not apply in Black Hole hexes.
Line Ship Addition:
- A line ship(s) is exempted from the disengagement penalty unless opposed by another line ship(s).
- A line ship is worth no points if faced on a 1v1 by a BCH or larger ship.