My suggestion was just to recognize adversaries not teammates as Dizzy did in order to build more respect across battlelines. So I'll stick to that method for mine.
1. Most feared PvP adversary
Tie, the F-14 and Dizzy, doubly bad in combo.
2. Best sportsman
Tough one here, but I'll go with a tie between Malak and Soreyes for doing Wild Geese duty.
3. Bravest stand against long odds
Wraith413, for defending an ISC planet and giving his ship for the cause despite impossible odds.
4. Most impressive performance in a single mission
Deadman 6 for nearly taking me out despite me having a better first battle pass, he surprised me with some big plasma and nearly turned my confidence into spacedust.
5. Most impressive performance overall
Die Hard for taking over the Alliance leadership under difficult conditions and managing to put together a fierce resistance where there was none before.
6. Most impressive improvement
The Alliance in general, the turnout the first weekend was horrible for them but they have really bucked up and stepped to the plate since.