Of course, like all of you, I can only rank according to my own experience... but here goes.
Feds:
1. 0Scotty0 (I can honestly remember people being excited if they managed to damage him before they died.)
2. TobinDax
3. Phoenix
Klingons:
1. Seki
2. KHH-Jakle
3. KHH-Shadowlord and KHH-Evil Kraven in a tie
Romulans:
1. Wisdom-iCoP (Watched a game film of him in an NHK taking on two undamaged BCF's after his wing made a terrible mistake and died in the first couple minutes. He waxed the two experienced Fed pilots. They could not believe it. Best Romulan pilot I have ever seen. And I have flown with quite a few.)
2. Pardek
3. AeHaILH
Gorn:
1. RedRightHand
2. Cobra
3. In my experience there has been no one on par with these two. And they were a team. Nearly unbeatable.
Hydran:
1. WildWeasel
2. PeetieTwo
3. Marcus
(All three are/were able to perform magic in this race.)
Lyran:
1. Wolverine (Master of the "Wolvey Shuffle")
2. Aragorn
3. Slider
Kzinti:
1. Green
2. Legendary
3. NiHM
ISC:
1. CaptainKirk-iCoP
2. [ISC] Phaser
3. Whippet
A very nice idea to bring this up. I just had a wonderful stroll down memory lane. Many thanks!
Duck and Kraven a tie?
Peenix was good as long as he got to dictate what ship his opponent was flying in terms.....take him out of his game and he's just another fed stinking of sheep
my own list
Fed:
1-Shogun (This was Kravens daytime buddy that regularly kicked Kraven's A$$) I think he was in DIF
2-Peenix (as long as he could get his way in terms)
Klink:
1-Seki (or Jaco)
2-Jaco (or Seki)
3-Spear
all MoK
Lyran:
1-Aragorn (any race)
2-Crimson Knight
3-Slider
all RaK
ISC:
1 MagnumMan (any race )
2-Capt Kirk (even though he was a real whiner when he lost)
3-Wisdom iCoP
all iCoP
Gorn:
1-Sassixx(did I get his name right?...ask Duck about the tourney we took 2nd place cause of me...argggg)
2-Peetie Two
3-Golem (honorable mention to his buddy Mars)
both from GE I think
Rom:
1-PGC-Graakna ("Delta is delta")
2-PGC Beaver
3-PGC-Graaks buddy(....I forget) Phynniris (now I remember)