Thanks for the comments, guys and gals. Here's the continuation.
Chapter Three
"I’m sorry? Could you repeat that please, Lieutenant?" Commander Sulafi sounds like he cannot believe his ears, and I have to say that he’s not alone in his attitude. I’m glad I’m sitting down as it saves me from falling off my feet. Urrih is choking on a large gulp of vodka he’d just downed.
Collecting my wits, I oblige the commander. "Sir, I repeat: I have made no request to my commanding officer for a transfer off this ship."
"Lieutenant..." Sulafi hesitates.
"This may become a serious issue. I’m going to have to get an acceptable explanation for this matter from you. If I’m not happy with what you tell me, it’s going to go above my office and maybe even into an official inquiry." I’m still trying to come to terms with the scope of McCafferty’s arrogant presumption in thinking that I’ll jump at the chance to get away from her, so I quietly say, "I understand, sir."
Urrih has stood up and is conveying his intent to leave. I signal my assent, and the door closes and locks after my friend’s departure while Commander Sulafi is occupied with his terminal. My mind is whirling, but I keep coming back to how badly McCafferty has misjudged me.
She may be better at tactics that I am, but she’s certainly misread my strategic aims. To have invited this level of attention over the matter she must truly believe that I desperately want to go. My thoughts are settling now, clarifying and coalescing. I’m also suffused with a roaring, intense anger and a desire to roast McCafferty over it.
I could completely shaft my dear captain in my answers to Sulafi’s questions, I realise. I could get exactly what I want, and with my own personal logs to back me up I could be as underhanded as McCafferty has obviously been.
I could have her disciplined, maybe even cashiered out of the Service. Urrih’s words come back to haunt me, though.
"Is your feud with Karen more important than your friendship with me?" My conscience aligns his point with current events. Is my feud with McCafferty more important than my duty to the truth?
My vindictive side roars its anger, trying to silence my conscience, but the quiet, rational voice creates it’s own null zone around it, allowing me to hear it quite clearly.
No. I will not stoop to lying and truth twisting to get my way. Mr. Vindictive howls his outrage, but to no avail. He is consoled with the thought that the evidence arrayed against her could be sufficient on its own to badly hurt her career, if not end it outright.
My seconds of reflection are over, however, as Sulafi returns his attention to me.
"I’m ready to hear your explanation now, Lieutenant Brown. Be aware that this conversation is now being recorded and taken into the official record. You are now bound by the terms and conditions applied to a witness in a Federation legal trial. If you are found to have lied or altered the truth in your testimony and it leads to further action, you will be placed under arrest. Do you understand?" I nod seriously. "I understand, Commander. I am ready to give my testimony."
"Very well. I need to know the situation aboard the Kusanagi
before I can ask any worthwhile questions. Please proceed." "Aye sir," I respond, and sit at attention in my chair. I then proceed to tell my story.
*****
Over an hour later and Commander Sulafi is finally satisfied. Through my narrative of events--which happened to miss out the actual telling of the catalyst event and only told of its results and effects--the commander had looked at turns thoughtful, puzzled, and bewildered. However, the longer I spoke, the more his expression edged into distaste and outright disgust.
Once told, he had actually said,
"Do you mean to tell me that this is the current command situation aboard one of Starfleet’s front-line starships?" in a tone of outright disbelief.
I had calmly confirmed this and the questioning began. Now that was over and he was about to sign off. He left me with a parting warning.
"Thank you for your testimony and you candour, Lieutenant, but this does not reflect well on either
of you. This situation is intolerable, unacceptable, and will not be allowed to continue. However, it goes above my head and I’ll have to inform my superiors. They will be in contact with both of you quite soon, and it will be their decision as to what will happen to both of you." I manage to repress a shudder, but it nonetheless feels like someone just walked over my grave. It also feels like the babysitter has caught us misbehaving, and will tell our parents when they return.
"Yes, sir," I say, then ask, "If that is all, sir?"
"It is for now, Lieutenant. You’ll be hearing from us. Starbase 22, out." The screen goes blank.
I relax from my ‘at attention’ pose and slump back into my chair.
Oh, fantastic. I’ve probably just got both of us fired. *****
I’m heading to my meeting with the captain. I’d grabbed a quick shower and donned a clean uniform, then arranged to talk to McCafferty "regarding a matter of the utmost priority". She probably knew I’d received a call from Starfleet and was no doubt expecting me, as she was ready with free time at 2000 hours. Since it’s almost another four hours before we expect to catch up with the escape pods, she’s no doubt ready to offer me a helpful kick out the airlock towards my new ship.
Boy, is she ever in for an unpleasant surprise.
Well, this is not something that she can
rationally pin on me, as she brought it upon herself. Regardless, I am
not looking forward to it.
I arrive at her quarters on the opposite side of Deck 3 in less than a minute, mentally fortifying myself for the impending storm, and press her door chime.
The door slides open and her voice calls out, "Come in, Mr. Brown. I’m at my desk."
Typical. Doesn’t even come to greet me. In any other situation, it would speak of an easy familiarity and friendship. All I get from it is her contempt of me. However, my little run-in with Commander Sulafi has reminded me that however I feel about the captain, my duty and responsibility are to the chain of command, and my respect for both
must carry over to the office, if not the person, of my CO.
"Aye, sir," I reply shortly and step inside, allowing the door to close and lock behind me. I can already feel my anger building again now that I’m about to come face-to-face with the person who basically just grabbed me from behind unawares and tried to throw me off their ship. My scare from Starfleet is fading, and although a bigger one is looming,
this is right here and now.
McCafferty looks like she’s finishing up some work on her terminal, but it’s probably just to make me wait some more. I sit down in the chair opposite and avoid looking at her, until she speaks again.
"Okay, Lieutenant, what’s this urgent matter that you need to discuss?" she asks, seeming to be in a good mood—which is wrong for a start, because she’s never
happy that I’m in her presence.
As if you don’t think
you know, back-stabber! All my conflict with her has been out in the open, for all that its childish, petty stuff. I decide to play it straight--chronologically speaking--and
then drop my load on her.
"Captain, not long ago I received a real-time transmission from the Starfleet Personnel Officer for this sector, informing me that he’d found a position for me aboard another ship. He had done so on receiving my request for a transfer, as endorsed by you." I look into her eyes and find a sense of anticipation there, and note in her whole body an almost nervous excitement, possibly brought about by my calm demeanour and steady tone. I ask, "Can I assume that you did indeed make this request on my behalf, and it’s not some mistake or prank by someone else?"
McCafferty was having some trouble holding still, but her voice was steady and firm. Indeed, her tone was faintly apologetic as she answered. "Yes, Lieutenant, I did."
I made to ask why, as I might as well hear her version of events or find out what she wants me to hear, but she continues after a brief pause.
"I made that request because I was fairly certain you would not do so yourself, based on what I know of your character. Despite the... problems... between us, you would have stuck it out in an attempt to do your duty. While that is an admirable quality, I find it self-defeating--if, indeed, not self-flagellating--in this case." Having gotten up to pace for her little speech, she now turns to look at me directly as she continues. "I thought it better for all concerned--"
And for you in particular, I silently add.
"--if I made this request for you. Even our professional relationship is not at its best, and its beginning to affect crew morale and possibly their performance. You are certainly not happy here, and to be perfectly candid, I’m not happy either. I cannot see this situation improving any time soon, but this is
my ship, and I’m not giving her up."
At that last sentence she let some steel enter her voice to show that she meant it. Although logical, and incidentally exactly the right thing to have done in such a situation, she had missed out one hugely important element and the only thing that mattered to me.
What
I want.
By not consulting me and keeping me out of the loop, she’d brought this on herself. Despite my own building anger I manage to calmly ask, "You didn’t think it wise to actually ask
me about any of this? That perhaps, if you had discussed this with me, I might have come to agree despite my ’dedication to duty’ and made this request myself?"
McCafferty looks wary of this question, but is again convinced by my lack of reaction or heat in my words that I have already accepted the transfer. She magnanimously allows my point.
"Admittedly, Mr. Brown, that’s what I would have done in any other situation. However, ours seems to be different. As I said, even our professional relationship is strained. I honestly didn’t think such a meeting would have been productive."
You mean it wouldn’t have produced the result you think you have now, I silently comment. By now my anger has had enough of me suppressing it to get admissions from our hated foe. In the moments before I let it loose, I realise in a pained way that I’m just proving her right about the meeting we never had.
"Gods’-damn you to
hell, McCafferty!
You had no right!" I explode at her. She looks completely taken aback and shocked at my rapid transformation, but rallies quickly. Still not completely understanding the situation, she offers a firm but restrained rebuke.
"That is
enough, Mr. Brown! I will not tolerate insubordination! I’ll ignore that one--and
only that one--because of present circumstances. Any more of that and you’re past being on report and going straight to confined to quarters!"
"Yes
Sir!" I snarl, desperately holding on to the far edge of subordinate behaviour. "Permission to speak freely, Captain?" I grate out.
Sensing now that all is not well, she snaps out, "Denied. You’re going to have to control yourself, Lieutenant."
"Very well,
Captain," I all but sneer. "For your information,
Sir, I am unhappy here but that is mainly
your doing. I have my own friends, the respect of the officers and crew, and I’m good at my job. For the record, I do
not want to transfer off and I have refused the position that Starfleet was good enough to find for me
at your behest."
McCafferty’s face, at first just angry, is now positively livid. It is a most impressive shade of purple, and I get a good measure of satisfaction from causing it. "
You--" she starts, venom in her voice and eyes, but I cut her off.
"
With respect, Sir, I’m not done," I say. Ratcheting up the contempt and disgust in my tone, I plunge on. "What you did was not only against regulations, it was underhanded, devious, undignified, and contemptuous of not only me as a person but also of my own oaths to Starfleet and my duty to the chain of command. Once again, you have tried to impose your will on your subordinates to get what you
personally want out of a situation, and either tried to bully or cut out those who don’t go along with you--"
McCafferty broke in there, eyes alight with the fury of battle. "Those are slanderous remarks, Brown, and I
will see you take them back! Has it also escaped your notice that ‘those who don’t go along with me’ consist solely of
you, an officer who has shown a distinct lack of respect, ability, and dedication to duty recently? That the rest of the crew seem to have no problem following my orders, and that your accusations against me are based solely on your own paranoid opinions of me and are not corroborated by even a single witness?"
"It’s only slander if its not true, Captain," I shoot back. "It is your opinions of my performance that are slander, and though you’re putting on a good show for the crew,
I know what’s behind it all. I now have two documented incidents where you have tried to play fast and loose with your orders and the regulations, where you’ve tried to bully subordinates in to submitting to your will. The fact that it is me you’ve been doing this to makes them no less valid or true."
McCafferty’s eyes had widened at a certain point during my last statement, and her next words confirmed my guess as to what tack she’d take next. It’s nice to know that I’m not the only one who could be predictable.
" ‘Documented incidents’, Brown? You’re taking notes, building up circumstantial evidence and putting your own slant on it?" she accuses, insinuation heavy in her tone. "How long have you been doing that? Long enough to think you can challenge me? That’s mutiny, Mr. Brown!"
Once again I thank my conscience for stifling the desires of my anger. Had there even been the slightest thread of truth to that comment, I’d have faltered in my cause--an event McCafferty would have noticed immediately and capitalised on to my detriment. My own thoughts on mutiny from earlier today helped me stabilise and ground myself against that charge so that I didn’t so much stop to rally as pause for breath.
"This isn’t anything close to mutiny and you know it, Captain. You do have all the power here, but
I’m here to ensure that it isn’t
absolute power. You can’t just steamroller over people who disagree with you, because in most cases--and this one in particular--the end does
not justify the means. You are trying to get rid of me, whether I want to go or not. You were so sure that you could force me into it one way or the other, or that I would be glad to be gone and wouldn’t care what you did to make it happen, that I wouldn’t contest it.
"And again, I’ve thwarted your will. That’s really what this is all about, isn’t it,
Captain?" I demand hotly. "You cannot stomach the fact that I won’t let you have
what you want, the
way you want it!"
That reached her. I saw something acknowledge the hit among that roiling mask of anger, and again her response was just to get me away.
"That’s it, I’ve
had it with your insinuations and accusations! You’re confined to quarters pending a disciplinary hearing to be convened when we get back to Starbase 22. If for any reason you have to leave your quarters, you’ll be escorted by a security guard--"
"Just hold on there,
Captain Sir, I’ve not yet discussed the reason for my urgent meeting," I break in angrily, "and since it directly affects you as well you’ll probably want to hear it."
Something in my tone makes McCafferty pause in reaching for the intercom. Part of me is actually hoping that she’ll go through with what she just threatened, so that when Starfleet Command does comes calling she’ll have no idea. Being completely unprepared for it, she will try to fudge her way out, explaining why I’m in the brig or whatever without knowing what I’ve already told Personnel.
She wavers for a second before deciding to hear me out.
Probably thinking she can always confine me later, no doubt. She makes a show of it nonetheless.
"Oh for--If you still haven’t spit it out yet, then what was all this for?" she angrily demands of me.
"I had some things I both needed to know and get off my chest," I say, still angry but under tight control again. I volunteer nothing further.
Matching my tone, McCafferty demands, "Well, out with it! What is the reason for you being here?"
Without any further preamble, I lay it out for her. "Commander Sulafi of Starfleet Personnel demanded an immediate answer for my refusal of the transfer, which I gave. He then questioned me extensively on my answer, and after an hour of talking to him, he declared the whole situation described by my answer as, and I quote, ‘intolerable, unacceptable, and would not be allowed to continue’. He also said that such a situation was above his level of office and would be passed on to his superiors, who would make the final decision with regards to us. The commander told me to expect further contact from them, directed to both you and me in the very near future. He didn’t give an exact time, but I’m thinking that it’ll be early tomorrow morning."
During my little recitation I had been searching out McCafferty’s reactions and true feelings to my dose of bad news, but they remained inaccessible behind a stone mask face and a ruthlessly still body. So I know nothing about what she thinks of this, whether it is panic that she’s brought such high-level attention to our little feud, more anger and hatred of me for forcing this issue into the light, or tactical options being considered for the achievement of her strategic goals. Before she can speak, I add my final thought.
"You’ve brought this upon yourself, Captain. I know you’ll still blame me, but even dismissing our recent problems, did you really expect me to cover your back while you were stabbing mine?"
"I expected you to--" she snaps out, before catching herself just in time. McCafferty looks annoyed with herself for letting that much slip, but I’m disappointed that she managed to hold back from saying something incriminating.
"Very well, Mr. Brown, you’ve won your reprieve since Starfleet Command will be wanting to talk to you. However," she warns, the threat implicit in her tone, "any further act of disrespect or insubordination will be instantly dealt with and resulting in your confinement to quarters and being relieved of duty until we reach the starbase. Is that understood?"
"Yes, Captain," I reply calmly. "So I can expect no further disrespect from you either, or similar charges will be just as instantly filed against you, sir?"
She almost gnashes her teeth at this, but cannot very well deny me. "That is correct, Mr. Brown. I’m glad we understand each other," she grates out. "Dismissed."
"Aye, sir."
I exit her quarters, leaving her deep in thought.
*****