Wow, lots of discussion here.
I played SFC1 and SFC2 in single player stuff til I was burned out. I never got into modded stuff though.
Just about the time i had put the games down SFC3 came out so I bought it. The few weeks I hated it and was really disappointed, having been used to EAW. i almost trashed it right then but i kept playing. Kept trying to see what it had in it to make it fun.
Eventually it grew on me. SFC3 is not the product I wanted to follow SFC2 but it is what it is.
With the latest patches to it SFC3 is truely a modders game. The stock version is bad and no one flies the ships the way they should be flown in the trek universe.
All SFC games have some things in common. SFC2 is a more technical game while SFC3 is a more of a pilots game. each have there strong and weak points and will not appeal to all.
Now here is where I will get in trouble:
Many in here want to try and turn SFC3 into a SFC:OP type game.
Those who tend to take it the other direction, toward an arcade game, tend to get bashed in here.
SFC3 will never be OP or EAW. Never. Just like they will never be SFC3.
We can add ships, change settings but we can't put elements into the game that just aren't there.
Only a handful of players can move back and forth between these games and be good. Most will tend to be in one camp or the other. The best we can achieve is mutual respect not unity.
"Seperate but equal" Just don't start hanging SFC2 only signs or tell us to sit in the back of the forum.