Im in 100% agreement with HEXX.
A mix of servers is what keeps people going. If they are all regimented, SFB/F+E types, your only catering to a portion of the player base, whereas on the other hand, if it is all 3 BB fleets flying around, with no rules, etc that will run off the more SFB/F+E types.
Have it like it always has been:
Fun servers, with no restrictions
Controlled servers, with Full/Limited OoB.
Perhaps a server with the systems Bonk and Gook have suggested as well, that would have to be more on the Full/Limited OoB I would imagine, but I suppose it could work on the Fun server as well.
I think GW2 was the best server I have played on yet. I liked SS2 as well, where you could BUY a BCH if you wanted, but if you died it gave VCs to the enemy.
While I prefer the GW2 type, or even a more restricted type OoB server, Im the type that I will pretty much play on anything that sounds good. Im sorry Dizzy's SG3 is gonna be for EAW, as I uninstalled that when I got OP and have no intention of taking a step backwards in my SFC play. (HOT chicks tho, Dizzy!
)
Make it however you want, as DH's poll showed, it appears that of the interested community that actually comes to the boards, its pretty much split right down the middle.
Seems to indicate we need both types of servers, and perhaps some blended servers that have both elements.
I frankly am skeptical of the DIP project, but hope to be proven wrong in LB5. Of course, as one of the "Evil SFB Purists" I dont like the idea of modifying things to make BCH's more like Tourney ships, nor do I like the idea of modifying things so historically slow hex flipping races can compete with the other races. Its not about "fair" its about picking the race you like.
Ah well, do as you will. I will happily try whatever you hard working boys and girls put out.