Topic: Forget Kirk, bring back Sisko! (Read 12991 times)

Scipio_66 · « **Reply #20 on:** April 16, 2004, 02:09:28 pm »

Quote:

What in the hells is your problem with Janeway?

Starship captains should not be seen with tears streaming down their cheeks because their first officer has hurt her feelings by disobeying her orders.

Starship captains should not offer "food and medical supplies" to an alien race in exchange for help. The aliens live on a freaking planet(s), for crying out loud, they already grow food to feed millions of people. How much food were you thinking to beam over from your little light cruiser? About the only things you could possibly trade that would be of any use to an alien empire are advanced tech, rare minerals found at distant systems, or your services as a mercenary. Since you aren't willing to trade two of those things than I suggest you start filling your hold with local gemstones as you travel from system to system or else solve your own problems.

(OK, actually that latter incident meant the the writing sucked, not that Janeway sucked. But I lost all interest in her as a commanding officer after that former incident.)

-S'Cipio

DonKarnage · « **Reply #22 on:** April 16, 2004, 03:22:45 pm »

bring sulu and riker back.

i have see a few episode of enterprise and it was bad, the timeline is mixt, the enconter the borg before picard encounter them, dahm whos the moron who hired the scrip guy, read the books and manual, watch theepisode of startrek, the tng, ds9 and voyager, get the 8 movies (the rest was also a bad script) so the will not badly make the next statrek serie (if the do make new one) if the do one before kirk but after the enterprise, like the daedalus class could be interesting if the dont mess it up like enconter with secies 8472, the planet killer, the probe from st4, or anithing that will append in the 23th and 24 century.

we should do script ourself since we know more that them.

Lieutenant_Q · « **Reply #23 on:** April 16, 2004, 04:01:14 pm »

do the scripts ourselves....

Thats Brilliant!!!! Maybe we can save Star Trek by submitting scripts for Enterprise...Most of us here could come up with better stuff than they put on UPN now anyway...I'd get started on that Idea, but I currently have other engagements. Maybe tommorow or Sunday, after I put up the next chapter of my story/script for ST:XI

Magnum357 · « **Reply #27 on:** April 16, 2004, 10:30:09 pm »

Guys... why the hell do I always hear a lot of bickering about "whos the best Captain" all the time? I think they are all awsome Captains, even Janeway or Sulu. If I was in Starfleet I would be honored too serve under them.

I thought Janeway was an interesting character actually. Their where a few incidents in Voyager where I think the had more Balls then Kirk in certain situations. And I must add that i enjoyed Seasons 4 through 7 much more then 1 through 3. Far better stories for the most part and the Voyager story actually had a little more Arc too it. the only bad thing I thought they really did was make the Borg a little easy too kill, but they still were scary in some situations during the series.

As for Archer, I think Bakula is not doing too badly as a Starfleet Captain, but as many people have pointed out, the story writing for the show is lackluster so it might be affecting the potential of the Archer Character. I also think Bakula, kinda over acts a tad too much like Kirk, but its just superfical at most and not really relevent.

As for Sisko, I know Brooks is not a great Star Trek fan (I can't blaim the guy, Star Trek actors usually have a hard time getting roles after Star Trek) but I thought he was one of the best Actors of all the series. His acting in some of the DS9 episodes almost made me cry (Gasp!) The guy has a lot of potential.

NannerSlug · « **Reply #28 on:** April 16, 2004, 10:42:24 pm »

i am dying here from laughter scippy. that is the best voyager impression i have seen yet. HA!

Maxillius · « **Reply #29 on:** April 17, 2004, 02:50:29 am »

The thing you gotta keep in mind about Archer is that he's not a Federation Starfleet captain, but an Earth Starfleet captain. We all know how the Earth military takes to being attacked, and there are only two crew members that are from different worlds on Enterprise, so Archer's attitude isn't tempered by the thoughts and feelings of 150 races of people. He takes Vulcan and Denobulan advice at times, but Enterprise is a HUMAN ship on a mission for EARTH with nothing else in mind besides retaliation for the Xindi attack.

Now, as Federation captains go, I think Picard has the attitude down cold, with Janeway a close second in that regard. Consider, Voyager is a light cruiser, and she was only supposed to be there 6 weeks, not 7 years. In that respect, Janeway made the best of the situation, but I think Picard or Riker would've handled things a bit differently. Kirk would've gone out of his cotton-pickin mind!

I just don't see a reason for Kirk, why he's so popular. And who's this Sisko guy?

Age · « **Reply #30 on:** April 17, 2004, 03:14:49 am »

I am not going to Entertain this one but I will agree with you Maxillius but I like it when Kirk goes out of his mind.I liked it in the Wrath of Kahn when he scream up at him from the planet down below.I want to see Kirk when he loses some lbs that is you see what not doing Star Trek has Done these people J Doohan has gianed waight to.It will be intesting to see the TNG crew in 10 years.

I am sometimes out of my mine d to that is why run into them with my ship off course.

not head

Sisko can be seen on DS9 on Spike @7PM pacific

Laflin · « **Reply #31 on:** April 17, 2004, 04:23:52 am »

I liked DS9 and Avery Brooks, but no one can chew lines like Bill Shatner - as proof watch him devour the Preamble in "The Omega Glory"

FFZ · « **Reply #34 on:** April 18, 2004, 09:00:16 am »

Janeway's eneptness caused the mission to be 7 years, Kirk would have found a better way staight away.

BTW, Kirk NEVER lost it in tough spots.

He's simply the best, the others are just pale reflections.

Age · « **Reply #35 on:** April 18, 2004, 12:07:41 pm »

I could of agree with you more if he were out there he would of gotten Scotty to develope a cloaking Devece for the Enterprise.They are not in Ferertion space so why stick to those rules just shove them out an air lock.He did things his way anyway or sometimes.

Magnum357 · « **Reply #36 on:** April 18, 2004, 04:22:08 pm »

You guys do have a point, a Cloaking device could have helped a lot for some of the situations that Voyager went through. And since they were not suppose too be in the Delta quadrant anyways, who is going too know that the Feds are not suppose too use cloaks.

ActiveX · « **Reply #37 on:** April 18, 2004, 04:36:18 pm »

I think what it comes down to is we each have our Captains, the ones we would be if we could...

They are as different as we are...

Tremok · « **Reply #38 on:** April 18, 2004, 05:41:34 pm »

Brooks is not coming back to Star Trek. He's been blacklisted. Sniff about and your find several comments that state to the effect "We would welcome every actor of DS9 back, except him"

Somewhat of a pity. Sisko is the only captain that ever showed some piss and vinegar. Archer has some potential. Picard, well, sometimes I swear I see him wear skirts. Kirk? Couldn't say, before my time, but seems to be too much of a playboy.

Janeway? I hope whoever put that whiney pissy soccer mom in charge of a ship dies and spends a horrible eternity burning in Hell. I hope my feelings in regard to her are clear.

News:

Topic: Forget Kirk, bring back Sisko! (Read 12991 times) var addthis_config = {"data_track_clickback":true};

Scipio_66

Merlinfmct87

DonKarnage

Lieutenant_Q

feargusf

Lepton1

Scipio_66

Magnum357

NannerSlug

Maxillius

Age

Laflin

Merlinfmct87

Merlinfmct87

FFZ

Age

Magnum357

ActiveX

Tremok

Maxillius

Topic: Forget Kirk, bring back Sisko! (Read 12991 times)