Topic: Why I hate Bob erm cloak I mean (Read 13056 times)

Toasty0 · « **Reply #60 on:** February 09, 2003, 07:20:33 pm »

Oh well, I think he messed with your head...but then I've flew with EvilBob for over 2 years. He is the master of smack talk. It all part and parcel of his tactics to shake you up. Obviously he succeeded.

He is also a master tactition. Imho, he used all options avaliable to him (without exploiting a cheat or bug) to avoid a loss.

If that frustrated you to the point that you had to come here and drag his name through the dirt then maybe you should evaluate your particiaption in the game and your sportsmanship or lack of before you play again.

Cloak is an option. In the face of overwhelming firepower I think you should use the cloak to either escape of frustrate your opponent into making a mistake(s). Like I tried to suggest in my earlier post I think you should take a step back from your anger and ponder whether or not Bob played the best game available to him...then ask yourself what would have you done and would that have been a warrior's best move?

Then go back and smack talk EvilBob...shake him up...and spank him like the poor misguided warrior that he is.

Btw, smacktalk is fun. It adds a dimension to the game few know how to enjoy.

ONLY REAL WARRIORS CAN SMACKTALK

Best,
Jerry

Alexander1701 · « **Reply #61 on:** February 09, 2003, 07:34:02 pm »

Basic Romulan Tactics: Fly towards the enemy, shoot
Advanced Romulan tactics: Fly towards the enemy, tractor, shoot
Live for more than 5 minutes Romulan Tactics: Fly towards the enemy, Shoot, cloak till plasmas recharge, repeat

Its just how it is. And NO ONE (well, no one playing romulan long) would decloak anywhere NEAR the principle firing arc. The Cloak/Strafe is just how it works, unless you're
A) In a fleet, or
B) Much bigger than the target.

NOTE: Defiant = BC

Fleet tactics are better. Fleet up 1 large ship with two small ones. Have the small ones lead. At the start, the big ship cloaks, gets very close to the enemy, and decloaks in perfect positioning, thus preventing flight. And simultaneously preventing the attack of seemingly helpless romulan Cls.

In all fairness, it IS wrong to just cloak and hide. Today, I was attacked by a human Klingon BoP on Act C, and he just cloaked and hid, hopeing I would run away. Given as I was flying with a wingman, and that both of our ships were much bigger than his, he had no chance. He wasn't trying to gain position. It's too easy to gain position on uncloaked romulans, he would have if he'd tried. He was just hiding. End of story.

Alexander

Scorpion · « **Reply #62 on:** February 09, 2003, 10:16:45 pm »

I am mostly a Klingon player (note my Klingon insignia

). I have found that it is very hard to stay cloaked for long before being targeted and yes, I too have found that all these fed ships are constantly using the follow-cloak bug on me. It really ticks me off that they always seem to know where I am.

It also makes me angry when people target my cloak knowing full well that it can't be repaired.

Well anyway, kudos to you Blitz for not cheating. I wish more fed players were more like you. I agree with you that using the cloak to hide or cloak-snipe is an irritating, sometimes time-consuming and cowardly act. However, I don't have much of a problem with people using the cloak to hide or to cloak-snipe because sometimes that is the only thing that they can do especially when going up against monstrous fed ships intent on ripping their hull to shreds (by the way, I am terrified of defiants). I know from experience that sometimes it is hard to go toe-to-toe with fed ships and that cloak-sniping is a very sound and viable tactic to use in this situation.

P.S.: By the way Blitz I read your whole post. I found it interesting.

Whiplash · « **Reply #63 on:** February 09, 2003, 11:10:02 pm »

The cloak is very vulnerable to abuse by players. Its a bad idea. Its a bad tool that requires player vigilance to keep it from creating horrendously long and boring battles. I was against it when it was first hinted at in the SFC3 rumors, and I'm that much more against it now that I've seen it in action. What we need is a semi-invisible cloak between this one and the SFC2 one. Or maybe an SFC2 style cloak that was more effective and balanced. With the current plasma being effectively a direct-fire weapon, it should be easier to balance.

W.

Pestalence · « **Reply #64 on:** February 09, 2003, 11:19:09 pm »

Whiplash,

it sounds like you prefer a more shoot and scoot game instead of a stradegy game.. defeating cloak (without using current cheats / bug exploits) is a part of strategy.... just remember the TOS episode "Balance of Terror" to get a feel for what cloak battle is all about.... and also remember that SFC series is not a Trek sim or a Space Sim.. it is a strategy game.... always has been... just consider SFC 3 as strategy lite...

Just wait until patch is out as several anti-cloaking cheats are fixed....

Alexander1701 · « **Reply #65 on:** February 09, 2003, 11:24:46 pm »

One thing I would like to see is the ability to travel between sectors under cloak. That's where cloak strategy comes in. Actual battles themselves should be fairly easy to detect, with cloak 1-3 being pretty much a formality. But then that's just my opionion. I could be wrong

Alexander

Subspace · « **Reply #66 on:** February 09, 2003, 11:32:32 pm »

what i cant stand is when your in a game & their is 1 rom & 3 feds & all i can see are probes every whear ...

Im at 1/4 impulse with a lvl 5 cloak & here comes 2 or 3 fedies with a bunch of probes to eat my A$$ up ...

Patch will help on probes & just a hair off phase in & out times ... just a hair ,,,, 1on1 cloak is pretty good in a group it can be hell

Whiplash · « **Reply #67 on:** February 10, 2003, 12:32:52 am »

Balance of Terror played out more like Kirk knew right where the Rom ship was. Most of the time, he had an extremely good notion of where the ship was, even when it wasn't registering on the scanners. When you consider that each hex in SFB (and thus each point of range in SFC1/2) is 10,000 miles, the old representation of cloak makes sense. There is enough gas and dust particles in space, not to mention fuel exhaust, that a ship's position can be known to within 10,000 miles. When I look at Balance of Terror, thats exactly how it seems to me.

The old way, cloak was a game of tactics. Now, its a guessing game.

Its not hard to tell where my preference comes from. I played SFB heavily for about 13 years, and still play it once in a while. I'm all about maneuver, range, and timing. Not guessing. Luck plays too great a role in this version of the cloak. There was luck the old way too, but it was not as dominant as hidden cloak causes it to be. I realize there is a strategy in hunting cloak, but its too much luck and too little skill for my taste. I know others like it, and maybe it shouldn't be done away with if most players like it. But it will forever reduce my enjoyment of this game.

W.

Artie · « **Reply #68 on:** February 10, 2003, 01:17:48 am »

I fly fed most of the time and I love the cloak in P v P. The suspense of where the opponenent is going to pop up is great. Like a submarine battle, whoever gets detected first is at a disadvantage.
Flying a fed ship (The RIGHT way without exploiting the bugs) you have to come up with different tactics to defeat the cloak. Crazy ivans, high energy turns, mine patterns, random warps, using the map to your advantage... you are forced to get into the mindset of the cloaker and to make it as hard as possible for them to score a crippling hit.
The cloak gives the advantage to the empires that use it correctly, because they know where you are, where you are going, what your shield/weapons status is, and you have no idea about their condition. Information that you base your decisions on how you fight your ship are not available and you have only a three second window, (sometimes less over the internet) to get some damage in before they unleash all hell.
The cloak, new weapons, customizable ships, and (to a lesser extent) officers add a strategic element to this game that, from my perspective, makes up for the decrease in micromanagement found in sfc 2.

Toasty0 · « **Reply #70 on:** February 10, 2003, 05:36:00 am »

Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't know this was a tribunal of public opinion. If that's what your post is about then I withdrawl my previous assumptions about you. They were set way too high.

I think you shouldn't play against EvilBob anymore. It's an honor you don't deserve.

Jerry
:::Toasty0 climbs into his asbestos fighting suit:::

Blitzkrieg · « **Reply #71 on:** February 10, 2003, 06:39:28 am »

Its not a tribunal on public oppinion, Im petitioning Taldren to add a feature to the game, that stops players from avoiding combat by cloaking and hiding on map.

Also as a place where expert players of this game come to post and discuss, if at the end they are agreed that my point of view is totaly wrong then I will have to accept that and choose to play accordingly. If this wasnt the case I woudlnt choose to post my irate oppinion on a public forum I would have done it in private.

Toasty you have said that what he did was actually a good tactic in your oppinion (Im assuming thats what you implied, could be wrong), thats fair enough. I have stated I wont play you if you consider this a valid stratagy, maybe I seem petty by saying this but Its not the case. I simply dont want to have to wait around in game for a fight to end, I have to wait long enough for it to start. What is it, 45 seconds after clicking attack you have to wait to see if they auto forfit or not. Further on top of that you have to wait for the computers to connect to each other, then you have to wait for the game to load which Ill be honest isnt that bad but 'eh' It can be annoying sometimes.

Honestly I was of the oppinion that no one in the right mind would dissagree with me, how could they I thought, its castiron for sure? Well I guess I must be acting unreasonable in some peopls eyes, but what are you supposed to do if this happens to you? Keep taking it? Complain to admin, what admin?

Your right Toasty I dont deserver to play this guy, no one does. I dont care about him anymore I stated this, I only want this feature added to the game. Ill continue to re-make my point if required though if needed.

Subspace · « **Reply #72 on:** February 10, 2003, 08:10:56 am »

its no worse than having a small ship warp every whear when he has no hull left ... Forever people will do this , just warp out or forfit ....

Romulans are every whear
Even with your wifes !!!

Azrael · « **Reply #74 on:** February 10, 2003, 02:15:57 pm »

Blitz,

You've already let Player X run you down and cause you bother.

Why build this tribute to his (questionably) tactical and definate psychological victory over you.

Toasty. Good for you for sticking up for your mate. If Player X is known to you as a good player, then fair play, but as a Taldren Moderator, I do not expect you to talk down to players like Blitz. It's immature and out of place for a Moderator to be acting in this fashion.

As a Moderator, people look up to you and respect what you have to say, so be more responsible in your posts.

Who am I to tell you this? Nobody special. You have a think about what I've said and decide for yourself if you want to take it on board.

If one thing is clear from all the posts on this thread, it's that Cloaking in the hope that your enemy will give up and disengage on you is for loser cheaters who you shouldn't waste your time with.

If that's what he was doing, then he's a loser cheater. If it's not, then he's a master strategist.

Move on. If you could turn back time, you could do something about this.

You can't.

Don't waste your time with him, and if you get the chance, teach him a lesson.

Toasty, I think you guys have made a brilliant game. Thanks for that.

Azrael

Blitzkrieg · « **Reply #75 on:** February 10, 2003, 02:34:49 pm »

Well in my search for a soloution to this problem I decided a moderated server was required. I went into GFL where I clattered from sector to sector and eventualy p'd off a Borg cube who took out 90% of my Saber in one go, he then asked for a reason to let me live. After convincing him I was just a rubbish newbie (wasnt hard, after all its sorta true) he told me to go to GFL and consider joining, which I applied to do.

So maybe this is the soloution, stay away from those unmoderated servers. I didnt want to be run off but I guess I ran myself off in the end, hope they let me in the GFL and teach me a few tricks and maybe I will eventualy be in an environment best suited to me (padded room anyone?).

I still think they should stop people doing it though, Taldren next patch you will be bombarded by emails from me demanding this feature! Im letting you off till then

Blitzkrieg

Re: Why I hate Bob erm cloak I mean

Aenigma

Re: Why I hate Bob erm cloak I mean

News: